Janome HD3000 Vs Singer 4423 Comparison In Detail

Janome HD3000 Vs Singer 4423 Comparison In Detail


Janome HD3000 and Singer 4423 are heavy duty sewing machines alright. But they are placed in different segments. The reason why 4423 became popular was its features, good stitch quality and that too in a very affordable range. Sewers who were looking for a good quality, affordable heavy duty machine found their answer in 4423. HD3000 on the other hand, stole the hearts due to its ability to perform for long hours without a dip in stitch quality. Its ability to go through multiple layers of thick fabrics like denim was the talk among sewers. Now let us compare these two wonderful machines in detail.

Janome HD3000 Vs Singer 4423 - Major Feature Differences

Both are heavy duty mechanical sewing machines. Both come with beginner friendly features like automatic needle threader, top drop-in bobbin, one-step buttonhole etc. Now let us have a look at the differences.

Built-in Stitches

The first feature difference you will notice is the built-in stitches. Janome HD3000 comes with 18 built-in stitches including a one-step buttonhole. Singer 4423 comes with 23 built-in stitches (denoted by last two digits of the model number) including a one-step buttonhole. So the Singer machine here has 5 extra stitches, which adds to the stitch variety.

Stitch Width

The maximum stitch width available on HD3000 is 6.5mm and that on 4423 is 6mm. It is not a huge difference but still it is a difference.

Motor Speed

In my opinion, the motor that comes with 4423 is a gem. It can sew really fast. 4423's motor can sew at a maximum speed of 1,100 stitches/min. This is almost serger like speed. We all talk about the features and affordability of Singer 4423, but for me, the motor is the main USP. Janome HD3000's motor on the other hand can only stitch at a maximum speed of 860 stitches/min. It might look a tad low in comparison, but it also does an exceptional job.

Build Quality

Even though both machines come with a 'heavy duty' tag, there is a fair use of hard plastic on external parts. In terms of build quality, I would rate Janome HD3000 higher than Singer 4423. It is also the heavier of the two. HD3000 weighs 18.7 lbs and 4423 weighs approximately 14.5 lbs. The difference in build quality is understandable as 4423 is placed in the affordable range and HD3000 in the slightly premium range.

Cover

Janome HD3000 comes with an included hard cover, whereas Singer 4423 comes with a soft cover only.

Editor comment

It is very difficult to pick a machine as both have their own merits and demerits. If you ask me, I will go with Singer 4423 for its extra stitches and more importantly, its affordability. However, if you plan to sew a lot of multiple layers of thick fabrics like denim on a consistent basis, then I will recommend Janome HD3000. 

Side by side comparison

FeatureJanome HD3000Singer 4423
TypeMechanical Heavy DutyMechanical Heavy Duty
Built-in Stitches1823
Automatic Needle ThreaderYesYes
Buttonhole Styles1 One-step1 One-step
Top Drop-in BobbinYesYes
Stitch SelectionDialDial
Adjustable Stitch Length/WidthYesYes
Stitch Width6.5mm6mm
Stitch Length4mm4mm
Adjustable Presser Foot PressureYesYes
Drop FeedYesYes
Free ArmYesYes
On Board StorageYesYes
Included FeetAdjustable Blind Hem Foot, Rolled Hem Foot, Sliding Buttonhole Foot, Zigzag footAll-Purpose Foot, Zipper Foot, Buttonhole Foot, Button Sewing Foot
Machine Weight18.7 lbs14.5 lbs approx
Warranty25 Year Limited25 Year Limited
Extra High Presser Foot LifterYesYes
CoverHard CoverSoft Cover

Similar products

Singer 9980 Review In Detail

Singer 9980 Review In Detail

<p>Singer 9980 is a sophisticated, feature packed advanced sewing machine. It has all the features you want. However, the monogram letters can improve a bit.</p>

Singer 14T968DC Review In Detail

Singer 14T968DC Review In Detail

<p>Singer 14T968DC will be an ideal serger for those who want overlock and cover stitch option in a single machine. The stitches have a professional finish.&nbsp;</p>

Janome HD3000 Review In Detail

Janome HD3000 Review In Detail

<p>Janome HD3000 is a great performer. Yes, it is a mechanical sewing machine, but at the same time it has some user-friendly features as well.</p>

Singer 4423 Review In Detail

Singer 4423 Review In Detail

<p>Singer 4423 has all it takes to be an excellent beginner sewing machine. However, we found some areas of improvement in our review.</p>